Tracking the evolution of Fixed Income trading
Over the past five years, fixed income markets have seen growth in electronic trading; a client survey suggests that growth has recently accelerated.
Advisory, finance and risk management services that connect your ideas to capital and power possibilities.
Learn moreProviding large corporate, government and institutional clients with a full spectrum of strategic advisory, financing and risk management solutions.
ExploreWe serve our institutional investor clients by helping them to understand developments in global markets and offering execution and risk management tools across each major asset class.
ExploreOur analysts strive to deliver differentiated market insights, actionable ideas and collaborative Research across asset classes.
ExploreView thought-leading highlights by our market experts and analysts from across Barclays Corporate and Investment Bank.
Learn moreDive deeper into the topics and trends shaping economies and industries with timely analysis and insights.
Macro Shifts Innovation Edge Solving Sustainable ExploreGet updates on what’s driving the latest changes in business and markets through our regularly recurring series.
The Flip Side 3 Point Perspective Impact Series ExploreRead news and stories about our business, our people and our work in the community.
Learn moreGo to Section
The global fixed income market totals about $130 trillion in outstanding debt. By comparison, global equities markets total about $42 trillion. Given the scale of the fixed income market, it is critical for traders to keep up with the latest global electronic trading trends driving execution in the market.
Electronic trading in the world’s fixed income market continues to evolve with expanded platforms and protocols, yet despite growing availability and ongoing innovations, demand for transactions involving requests for quotes (RFQ) isn’t going away.
“RFQ is the way the majority of trades are being placed,” said Matthew Coupe, Head of Cross Asset Market Structure for the Global Markets business at Barclays. “It’s starting to evolve, but RFQ is not dead. It’s still the answer to ensure you can access material liquidity.”
To betted understand the latest trends, Coupe and the Market Structure team conducted a Global Client Fixed Income Markets Structure Survey, drawing over 260 responses from asset managers, central banks, banks, corporations, hedge funds, insurance companies and other institutions. This wide range of respondents represented institutions with fixed-income assets under management ranging from $10 billion to $200 billion.
Respondents came from three global regions: the Americas with nearly half of the activity; Europe, the Middle East and Africa, also with close to half; and the Asia and Pacific region with the balance of the activity. They also represented rates & credit, for both cash & derivatives.
The survey posed nearly 50 questions regarding trading tools and protocols; execution solutions and strategy; best execution and trader performance analysis; dealer selection; and regulatory change.
Here are three of the survey’s key findings.
Fixed income markets have enjoyed growth in electronic trading in recent years, but our most recent survey shows the pace of electronic trading adoption remained steady in 2021 compared to our survey of 2020 activity. The COVID-19 pandemic likely played a role.
While the survey showed more people are adopting different trading methodologies, a significant number still use RFQ for 75% or more of their flow.
Q: What proportion of your competitive Electronic Rates trades (tickets) are RFQ?
Over the past five years, fixed income markets have seen growth in electronic trading; a client survey suggests that growth has recently accelerated.
Source: Barclays 2022 Global Client Fixed Income Markets Structure Survey
Additionally, most respondents said they expect their use of click-to-trade to remain about the same – another indication RFQ is still in demand.
Q: If you use Click-to-Trade, do you expect to change your use of it over the next 12 months?
Source: Barclays 2022 Global Client Fixed Income Markets Structure Survey
Traders are investing in an increasing number of data sources and integrating these data streams in innovative ways. They are automating data on axes, dealer pricing, venue pricing, quantitative counterparty performance and more. They’re refining these tasks to not only analyse investment decisions, but understand market depth.
Q: What do you use the integrated data for?
Source: Barclays 2022 Global Client Fixed Income Markets Structure Survey
As the task of collecting, integrating and analysing so many data streams grows increasingly complex, more than half of respondents reported that they’ve either hired, or are looking to hire, data analysts. Core objectives for these analysts would include understanding market trends and feeding into the investment cycle, studying execution performance and training the next fixed income trader.
Survey respondents have reported an increase in price fragmentation year over year. This is defined as getting a different price from the same dealer when requested within a similar time frame.
Q: Have you observed pricing fragmentation on trading platforms? Definition - Pricing fragmentation would be defined as getting a different price from the same dealer when asked within a similar time period on two different platforms.
Source: Barclays 2022 Global Client Fixed Income Markets Structure Survey
On the rates side, over 20% of respondents said that they know platform-specific costs are factored into the prices they receive from at least some dealers. For credit, nearly 30% said they understand this.
As trading and market data streams accelerate in speed and complexity, fixed income traders will increasingly rely on technology and staff to manage it – constantly evaluating performance and finding new ways to execute.
1. Source: International Capital Market Association, https://www.icmagroup.org/Regulatory-Policy-and-Market-Practice/Secondary-Markets/bond-market-size/
2. Source: Statista, https://www.statista.com/statistics/242745/volume-of-global-equity-trading/
About the expert
Matthew Coupe
Global Head of Cross Asset Market Structure